How do you know when you’re wrong if you’re convinced you are right?

by drm on July 5, 2010

Go read this five-part blog series from Erroll Morris and then ask yourself the question, How do I make sure that I know when I’m wrong?

Morris is writing about a condition termed Anosognosia, which you can broadly define as not having a clue how wrong you are. No matter how smart we are, none of us are exempt from the condition: we all will encounter the famous “unknown unknowns” that influence our life on a macro- and micro- scale.


As one expert tells Morris:

But when you’re incompetent, the skills you need to produce a right answer are exactly the skills you need to recognize what a right answer is.

The challenge for those of us who are in positions in responsibility is to minimize the potential for anosognostic behavior as much a possible.

The most important way to do this on a daily basis is to try to see things through other people’s eyes. When someone presents an alternative point of view, no matter how aggressively or impolitely, we are obligated to try to understand how that point of view makes sense to them.

When you are in a position of putative power and authority this is one of the hardest disciplines to exercise. But it is one of the most important.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share
  • http://topsy.com/www.viralhousingfix.com/2010/07/05/how-do-you-know-when-youre-wrong-if-youre-convinced-you-are-right/?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2 Tweets that mention How do you know when you’re wrong if you’re convinced you are right? | Dan McCarthy’s ViralHousingFix — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Eric Brown, danielrmccarthy. danielrmccarthy said: New post: How do you know when you're wrong if you're convinced you are right? http://bit.ly/aGmjaI [...]

  • UrbaneWay

    Hi Dan,
    The Erroll Morris series are pretty thought provoking and an excellent read, thanks for sharing them. In contrast most breakthrough occur when everyone else is telling you that you are wrong, and so lives the dichotomy. Couple all that with the challenging economic climate we are all navigating, and decisions become dizzying.

  • http://mbrewergroup.com mbrewer

    Sounds akin to the 4 stages of learning:

    1. Unconscious Incompetence

    “I don't know that I don't know how to do this.” This is the stage of blissful ignorance before learning begins.

    2. Conscious Incompetence

    “I know that I don't know how to do this, yet.” This is the most difficult stage, where learning begins ­ and where the most judgments against self are formed.

    3. Conscious Competence

    “I know that I know how to do this.” This stage of learning is easier than the second stage, but it is still uncomfortable and self-conscious.

    4. Unconscious Competence
    (via http://processcoaching.com/fourstages.html)

    I would venture to say that the chance of any one person [read: leader] getting to and maintaining anything resembling unconscious competence is nearly impossible in an ever changing landscape. The only chance dates back to a philosophy preached by the late great Napoleon Hill – The Master Mind Principle – which suggests the wisdom and counsel of past, present and future leaders [mix in a little deity] coming together in unity of thought produces better clarity for all. Even at that – we now have to toss in the wisdom of crowds, thick skin and to speak to one of your points – a very open mind.

    Hope your holiday was a great one -